During the forty years that the Israelites wandered the desert after leaving Egypt, they faced many hardships, most notably a scarcity of food. To resolve this particular issue, God kindly provided the Israelites with “bread from heaven”. It was a “fine, flake-like thing, fine as frost on the ground” and “It was like coriander seed, white, and the taste of it was like wafers made with honey” (Exodus, Chapter 16).
They called “manna.” Hence the phrase: Like Manna from heaven
Today’s post deals with a substance called Manna, a group of Israeli scientists, and maybe a kind of salvation for people with Parkinson’s disease.
In 2013, in the Journal of Biological Chemistry, a group of Israeli scientists published the results of a study that suggested the sweetener ‘Mannitol’ (also known as Manna sugar – I kid you not) may be useful in the treatment of Parkinson’s disease.
A spoon full of Manna. Source: Qualifirst
What is Mannitol?
Mannitol is a colourless sweet-tasting, poorly metabolized crystalline alcohol sugar that is Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved as an osmotic diuretic agent.
In English: a sweetener.
Stick it on your tongue and it tastes like sugar.
Usually made from fructose and hydrogen, Mannitol increases blood glucose to a lesser extent than sucrose, and so it is commonly used as a sweetener for people with diabetes or sugar intolerance. The fact that Mannitol can be produced artificially is the only reason that it is often referred to as an ‘artificial sweetener’, but it does not fall into the same class as proper artificial sweetener, such as aspartame.
So what does the research say?
Title: A blood-brain barrier (BBB) disrupter is also a potent α-synuclein (α-syn) aggregation inhibitor: a novel dual mechanism of mannitol for the treatment of Parkinson disease (PD).
Authors: Shaltiel-Karyo R, Frenkel-Pinter M, Rockenstein E, Patrick C, Levy-Sakin M, Schiller A, Egoz-Matia N, Masliah E, Segal D, Gazit E.
Journal: J Biol Chem. 2013 Jun 14;288(24):17579-88.
PMID: 23637226 (This study is OPEN ACCESS if you want to read it)
The Israeli scientists were interested in the ability of Mannitol to inhibit the formation of alpha synuclein aggregates (clumps of the protein that is associated with Parkinson’s disease). Chemicals similar to Mannitol have exhibited protein destabilizing properties, so it was an interesting idea to test.
The researchers used different concentrations of mannitol and added it to a solution of alpha-synuclein. They left this concoction shaking for 6 days (at 37°C) and then assessed the levels of aggregation. Curiously the low levels of Mannitol had the strongest inhibitory effect, while the higher concentrations had no effect. The researchers repeated the experiments and found similar results.
Given this success, they turned their attention to an animal model of alpha synuclein: a genetically engineered fly that produces a lot of alpha synuclein. They found that Mannitol treated flies had significantly less alpha synuclein aggregation in their brain than untreated flies. This study was then repeated in genetically engineered mice (that produce too much alpha synuclein) and guess what? They found the same results.
These results led the scientists to suggest that “mannitol administration in combination with other drugs could be a promising new approach for treating PD and other brain-related diseases such as Alzheimer disease”.
It is believed that that aggregation of alpha synuclein (and the presence of Lewy bodies) is one of the pathological hallmarks of Parkinson’s disease, and thus any substance that inhibits that aggregation would potentially be beneficial.While there is a lot of experimental evidence to suggest that aggregated alpha synuclein is involved in the cell death associated with Parkinson’s disease, it is yet to be determined that inhibiting that aggregation would be beneficial. There are clinical trials going on as we write, so we should have an answer to this issue shortly.
A warning regarding Mannitol
Before you rush out and start loading up on Mannitol there are a few things you should know about it.
It is used medically, usually to treat increased pressure within the skull.
It should not be abused, however, as it can have an osmotic effect (in particular, attracting water from the intestinal wall). Consumed in excess, it will cause diarrhea, abdominal pain, and excessive gas.
In addition to intestinal problems, Mannitol has also been associated with worsening heart failure, electrolyte abnormalities, or low blood volume. We also do not know what effect it may have on absorption of L-dopa and other Parkinson’s disease medications.
EDITORIAL NOTE HERE: Whenever we discuss new experimental drugs and treatments on SoPD, we point out to the reader that what we are presenting here is experimental research. Under absolutely no circumstances should anyone reading this matter consider it medical advice. Much of what is presented are novel results that need to be replicated and verified before being considered gospel (this certainly applies to the current post). Before considering or attempting any change in your treatment regime, please consult with your doctor or neurologist.
The Header for today’s post is a depiction of manna from heaven. Source: History.com
17 thoughts on “Manna from heaven? Mannitol and Parkinson’s disease”
Wel, as a fly Parkinsons worker, it’s intriguing that they only report data for the A53T fly and not for the alpha synuclein wild type
Interesting. Makes a lot of sense.
More research is needed and Randomised control trials in required.
please give info about who and where can I buy manitol in Israel
Hi Jshira, thanks for your message. Unfortunately we don’t know where products can be bought on a country by country basis, but you should be able to find a supplier online. Before doing so, however, please note the health warning at the bottom of the post dealing with Mannitol and discuss it with a medical physician before making any life style changes.
We have had several attempts to post personal contact details in the comments section here (regarding where to obtain Mannitol). Unfortunately, we do not allow this – we can not be sure about the validity of any personal details being posted on the SOPD website, but we are responsible for any information provided here. So our policy is very simple: no personal contact details. We apologise for this, but we feel this is the best way to handle the matter.
What is the best recommended dose to take each time with the Te or Milk per example? B. Harel
Thanks for your message. Unfortunately, we can’t answer these sorts of questions. You could try asking the folks at Clinicrowd ( http://clinicrowd.info/introduction/ ) about this, but I would definitely suggest that you discuss taking mannitol with your doctor before trying anything. Dosing will vary on a person to person basis, so what works for one individual may not work for another. And some individuals may have pre-existing conditions that mean they should not be taking mannitol at all (eg. a history of heart or kidney issues). Hope this helps.
Is there anything that can be done when u have a neurogenic bladder with Parkinson’s
Dear Lisa, humblest apologies. Have just found your message in the inbox. Not sure why your message was so delayed in coming to us.
To your question regarding a neurogenic bladder, here at SoPD HQ we fully recommend you have a look at this website on the topic:
There is a small section about Parkinson’s on page 4:
And then treatment options are discussed on page 6:
We are not experts on this particular topic, but if you would like more information we can put you in contact with people who can provide.